Construction & Proportion

Shirt Fits & Silhouettes

How a formal shirt is cut matters more than almost anything else about it. This chapter explains the four main silhouettes, the seven points where fit is decided, and how to judge a shirt in the mirror.

A man in a fitted black long-sleeved shirt worn untucked with blue jeans, standing in a grey studio
Fig. 1A close, clean line through the body, worn untucked.

Four Silhouettes

Slim, regular, tailored & contemporary

Fit names are not standardised; one maker's “tailored” may be another's “slim”. Use these descriptions as a guide to the shape, then judge the actual shirt on your body. The gold line marks the chest, the wine line the waist.

Slim fit silhouette

Slim Fit

Closest to the body

A closer silhouette designed to follow the body. The chest is trimmer, the waist noticeably shaped (often with back darts) and the sleeves narrower. Slim shirts look sharp under a fitted jacket and suit lean or athletic builds.

Chest
Minimal ease
Waist
Strongly tapered
Best for
Slender frames, fitted suits
Regular fit silhouette

Regular Fit

Traditional ease

A more traditional silhouette offering additional room through the chest, waist and arms, falling fairly straight from armpit to hem. Comfortable for long days and broader builds, and forgiving when sitting for hours.

Chest
Generous
Waist
Straight
Best for
Comfort, broader frames
Tailored fit silhouette

Tailored Fit

Balanced

A balanced silhouette combining structure and comfort. There is gentle shaping at the waist to remove excess fabric, while the chest and arms keep enough room to move. For many people, this is the most versatile choice.

Chest
Moderate
Waist
Gently shaped
Best for
Most builds and offices
Contemporary fit silhouette

Contemporary Fit

Modern proportion

A modern interpretation of formal shirt proportions. It is typically clean through the body with a slightly shorter, straighter hem, so it can be tucked for work or left out for smart-casual settings.

Chest
Moderate
Waist
Lightly shaped
Best for
Versatile, smart-casual

Not every cut is available in every style or at every time. If you are visiting Options Mall for a particular fit, call ahead to ask what is currently in store.

1Shoulder seam2Collar3Chest4Waist5Sleeve length6Cuff7Shirt length

Anatomy of Fit

The seven fit points

Check these in order. The first two are the hardest to alter, so they should be right from the start.

  1. Shoulder seam placement

    The seam joining sleeve to body should sit at the outer edge of your shoulder bone. Too far in pulls; too far down the arm makes the shirt look borrowed.

  2. Collar fit

    Buttoned, you should be able to slip one finger — two at most — between collar and neck. The collar should not gape or crease the skin.

  3. Chest allowance

    Buttons should lie flat with no horizontal pulling or gaps between them, including when you sit and reach forward.

  4. Waist shaping

    A little excess fabric is normal. A balloon of cloth above the belt means the waist is too full; tight drag lines mean it is too slim.

  5. Sleeve length

    With arms relaxed, the cuff should reach the base of the thumb or the wrist bone, and not ride up far when you bend the elbow.

  6. Cuff positioning

    Under a jacket, show roughly a centimetre of cuff. The cuff should be snug enough not to slide over the hand.

  7. Shirt length

    A tucked shirt needs enough length to stay in when you raise your arms — usually covering the seat. An untucked shirt should end around mid-fly.

Reading a Silhouette

Shape, seen flat

Laid flat, a shirt reveals its cut. Compare the taper from chest to hem, the sleeve width and the shoulder line. Solid colours make the shape easiest to see.

Navy shirt with fine stripes laid flat
AFine navy stripe — straight, regular body
Black shirt with subtle shadow stripes
BShadow stripe — gently tapered
Olive solid shirt laid flat
COlive solid — relaxed shoulder
Mint green solid shirt with chest pocket
DMint solid — straight hem

Finding your fit

Start with your neck and sleeve measurement or the size that fits your shoulders, then choose the silhouette. If you are between fits, choose the roomier one: excess fabric at the waist can be taken in by a tailor, but a tight chest cannot be let out.

Remember that fabric affects fit. Stretch blends allow a closer cut without restriction, while crisp poplins feel firmer. Most cotton shirts can shrink slightly in their first washes, so a shirt that is tight in the collar on day one may become uncomfortable.

Finally, sit down in the shirt. Many shirts look fine standing and pull at the buttons when seated. A good fit is one you forget about by mid-morning.

For a step-by-step checklist, see the Men's Formal Shirt Style Guide.

Proportions

Tucked & untucked

Formal shirts are designed to be tucked. Their curved tails and longer backs keep them in place. Shirts meant to be worn out are cut shorter and straighter.

Tucked shirt silhouette with belt line

Tucked

For suits, ties and all formal business settings. The waist should blouse only slightly over the belt. A shirt that keeps coming untucked is too short or too full at the waist.

Shorter untucked shirt silhouette

Untucked

Reserved for smart-casual settings. Choose a shirt with a straighter, shorter hem that ends around the middle of the trouser fly. A long formal shirt worn out looks untidy.

Plum solid shirt laid flat

Fit first, then everything else.

Once the silhouette is right, fabric and detail can do their work.